Through a Glass Darkly (Editorial by Rob Renfroe)

Recently I read an editorial in the magazine Good News: Leading United Methodist to a Faithful Future. The article entitled, Through A Glass Darkly, focused on the Special General Conference to be held in February and the decision on human sexuality in our denomination as we move forward. Is there any hope? Yes, God is good and God is sovereign I believe he still has a plan for the people called Methodist.” Read it, pray about it and may the Holy Ghost lead you in forming an informative decision.   – Pastor Stan   <!–split–>

What will happen at the special General Conference this February? Right now, it’s anyone’s guess.  We see through a glass darkly, not able to predict with confidence what the delegates will do and knowing that God can always surprise us and provide a solution to our problems that none of us imagined.  Frankly, that’s what I’m praying for.

However, there are a few options that, at this point, seem most likely.  Two that we can take off the board are the Simple Plan and the Connectional Conference Plan.

The Simple Plan goes too far.  It redefines marriage as two adults, condones sex outside of marriage, prevents conservative annual conferences from refusing to ordain practicing gay persons, and allows pastors throughout the connection to marry gay couples.  Whenever similar proposals have come before General Conference in the past, they have been defeated by a wide margin.  The majority of the UM Church has not yet moved this far in a progressive direction.

The Connectional Conference Plan (CCP) creates three jurisdictions, each one with a different sexual ethic.  No coalition has formed to support it and no group is doing the hard work of promoting it to the rest of the church.  The CCP requires numerous constitutional amendments and there is little likelihood that a super majority of both General Conference delegates and then later of annual conference delegates around the globe will support it.

The plan with the greatest likelihood of passing is the Tradition Plan (TP).  It maintains our present position of affirming the worth of and welcoming all persons to the ministries of the church without allowing for practicing gay persons to be ordained or for our pastors to marry gay couples.  The Traditional Plan has several provisions that would allow the church to enforce the Book of Discipline more effectively when pastors and bishops violate our policies.  Each of these provisions will need to be approved individually.

Why is the TP most likely to pass?  Because it is most in line with what delegates have supported at every General Conference since 1972.  It was the plan that the majority of the delegates supported less than three years ago in Portland – most of whom will be voting again in St. Louis.  Whether all of the enhanced accountability measures can be passed remains to be seen.  But it is most likely that a Traditional Plan of sorts will prevail. And a Traditional Plan provides the most hopeful path to a faithful future for the United Methodist Church.

(part 2 continued in March Chimes)